r Qui vit encore

Nicolas Wadimoff, Switzerland, 2025o

s
vBack

The outlines of Gaza and its towns, depicted as simple white lines against the black backdrop of a dark hall: in this setting, nine refugees recount their former lives and the loss of their livelihoods and countless loved ones as a result of the Gaza War. By sharing their stories, they seek to reaffirm their sense of self and their sense of belonging.

This film is the perfect counterpart to Nafta, currently in cinemas, which examines the calculated fury with which the Israeli government and its army responded to the Hamas massacre of 7 October 2023: there, the devastating momentum of the Israeli war machine; here, the endless suffering of its Palestinian victims. In other words, Who Is Still Alive is not a film of political analysis, although its Geneva-based director Nicolas Wadimoff would probably disagree, but “merely” a snapshot of such artistic mastery that it becomes all the more devastating. There is no account of the origins of the century-old Israeli-Palestinian conflict and its cycles of violence, let alone any vision of how to resolve it. Instead, we are offered this: nine Palestinians who have fled to Egypt, ranging from a teenage girl to an elderly man, bear witness to what happened to them after 7 October – a date whose events they steadfastly refrain from mentioning. They do so in a large hall against a black backdrop that deliberately obscures any sense of place. Only the outlines of the Gaza Strip and the locations of their former homes are marked out in white paint on the floor, which they describe in greater detail during an initial round of testimonies. Thereafter, apart from a few moments of respite in dialogue or outdoors, there are only their stories: how the relentless bombardments first plunged them into fear and terror, then robbed them of their homes, their homeland and their loved ones. Wadimoff and his team stage these testimonies with great sensitivity, knowing when to withdraw where words fail and how to introduce carefully judged pauses. Above all, in the film's second half, they transform their intimate yet sweeping account of the suffering of war into an irresistible symphony of faces and voices, sometimes racing, sometimes faltering, as they recount the countless facets of pain and grief, before coming together in a collective song mourning the loss of their homeland. Here, war no longer appears as the continuation of politics by other means, but as the very negation of humanity.

Andreas Furler

Recommendationso

Movie Datao

Other titles
Who is Still Alive EN
Genre
Documentary 
Running time
113 Min.
Original language
Arabic
Ratings
cccccccccc
ØYour rating8.0/10
IMDB user:
8.0 (50)
Cinefile-User:
< 3 votes
Critics:
< 3 votes

Cast & Crewo

Jawdat KhoudaryHimself
Mahmoud JoudaHimself
Adel AltaweelHimself
MORE>
We use cookies. By continuing to surf on cinefile.ch you agree to our cookie policy. For details see our privacy policy.